Cinema Discourse

  • Home
  • About
  • Books
  • Classic Movies
  • Articles
  • Contact
  • Cookie Policy

John Lobell – John David Ebert

Movies as Theoretical Narratives


Cinema discourse looks at current and classic movies from a literary point of view. We also have top movie reviews, current movie reviews, film ratings, movie blogs and movie history.
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / On Black Swan

On Black Swan

December 21, 2010 By John Lobell 3 Comments

Black Swan: A Movie Review

by John Lobell

A female ballet dancer in a New York Lincoln Center company has for too long been passed over, but now she has been chosen for a role in a reworked Swan Lake which will require her to dance both the role of the pure White Swan, and the aggressive erotic Black Swan.  She is perfect for the White Swan, but her sexual repression keeps her from capturing the Black.  The movie presents her sexual/artistic (they are one) awakening.

This involves dreams, symbols, and sex (hot ballerina lesbian sex).  How do the critics handle this? Manohla Dargis’s review in the New York Times captures the movie with such phrases as: A witchy brew of madness and cunning / visceral and real / giddy, sometimes sleazy exploitation-cinema savvy / hammering her toe shoes into floor much as Jake La Motta pounded his fists into flesh / surprises despite its lusty or rather sluttish predilection for clichés / trippy psychodrama / a sexcapade / slow-creeping hallucinatory flights of fantasy / one delirious, phantasmagoric freakout.

Yes, all of that is there.  But there is a simple story here that few critics tell, perhaps because it is too obvious.  Nina, our ballet dancer, is artistically limited by her failure to grow up and her repressed sexuality.  Here we are reminded more of André Gide’s The Immoralist than of the Red Shoes.  In The Immoralist, Michel is a promising scholar, but completely repressed.  The story follows his plunge into the North African desert, which parallels the opening of his inner self that leaves his young bride dead.

The Black Swan opens with a dream announcing that what will follow will be the discovery of her sexuality.  The announcing dream opening is common, but most prominently used in Bergman’s Wild Strawberries, where the dream announces that time will stop and our elderly physician will be able to revisit and reevaluate his past to find the source of his numbness to life.

Nina appears to be also having mental problems.  On the way to work, she encounters herself on the subway.  As the movie progresses, she has more and more erotic and violent experiences that might or might not be real.  But the movie allows us to accept these experiences as perhaps just heightened artistic sensibility.  The movement of the story line is simple and direct.  Nina is rejecting her over-protective mother and her childhood, and opening to her aggressiveness, competitiveness, and sexuality, and integrating them into her art.  In the final scene she lies on her back, blood spreading over her white tutu from a self-inflicted vaginal shaped wound in her lower abdomen.  Her sexuality is open and her art is complete.

There has been a spate of books over the past several years telling us that we are all intelligent, we are all creative, and even that there is genius in all of us. It just isn’t so, and the destruction and creation involved in real creativity is more chilling than these books would have us believe. In a way, that is what The Black Swan is about. Creativity begins with upbringing, and the movie presents us with the sacrifice Nina’s mother has made in preparing her to be a ballerina. Then mastery, the years of disciplined practice. Expressing one’s soul—in Nina’s case, bringing her erotic self to the surface and integrating it with her angelic self. And finally, being in the world—having something to say and manifesting it for an audience in the world as it is.

In exploring creativity, one can’t do better than look again at Nietzsche’s “Three Metamorphoses of the Spirit” in Thus Spoke Zarathustra, where he presents his parable of the camel, the lion, and the child. And the dragon. It could be an outline for The Black Swan. Nietzsche writes:

“Of the three metamorphoses of the spirit I tell you: how the spirit becomes a camel; and the camel, a lion; and the lion, finally, a child.

There is much that is difficult for the spirit, the strong, reverent spirit that would bear much: but the difficult and the most difficult are what its strength demands.

What is difficult? asks the spirit that would bear much, and kneels down like a camel wanting to be well loaded… like the camel that, burdened, speeds into the desert, thus the spirit speeds into its desert.”

In the loneliest desert, however, the second metamorphosis occurs: here the spirit becomes a lion who would conquer his freedom and be master in his own desert. Here he seeks out his last master: he wants to fight him and his last god; for ultimate victory he wants to fight with the great dragon.

Who is the great dragon whom the spirit will no longer call lord and god?“Thou shalt” is the name of the great dragon. But the spirit of the lion says, “I will.” “Thou shalt” lies in his way, sparkling like gold, an animal covered with scales; and on every scale shines a golden “thou shalt.”

Values, thousands of years old, shine on these scales; and thus speaks the mightiest of all dragons: “All value has long been created, and I am all created value. Verily, there shall be no more ‘I will.'” Thus speaks the dragon….

To create new values–that even the lion cannot do; … what can the child do that even the lion could not do? Why must the preying lion still become a child? The child is innocence and forgetting, a new beginning, a game, a self-propelled wheel, a first movement, a sacred “Yes.” For the game of creation, my brothers, a sacred “Yes” is needed: the spirit now wills his own will, and he who had been lost to the world now conquers the world.

(This abbreviation is from Walter Kaufmann’s translation. You can find the whole parable online.)

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Comments

  1. Garett Strickland says

    December 26, 2010 at 9:29 am

    Most interesting for me was the importance of overcoming duality in reference to the action she takes with her ‘double’, represented in both a macrocosmic and microcosmic context in the film. Her means of assimilation and expression also being a kind of toll she pays, culminating in the final scene in the film. Let’s not forget, too, the subtlety of the pet name applied at the end, and the link it provides to Wynona Ryder’s character, who wasn’t lucky enough to get out so early… though perhaps that seems cynical.

    There’s also a very interesting thread of parent as primary seducer. The fact that every source of external seduction is crystallized into what develops as the dark seduction of the self — she slays a dragon — is redemptive, yes. But is the price of what’s perfect merely death by mirror?

  2. abbeysbooks says

    May 23, 2011 at 9:44 pm

    I also reviewed Black Swan through Nietzsche, Foucault and Baudrillard. You might like to take a look. I enjoyed your take on it.

  3. Zach says

    November 15, 2012 at 1:21 am

    The ballerina’s split subjectivity comes from the expectation of her to perform contradictory roles: the elegant and innocent Nina and the lusty and seductive Lily. The tension of embodying aesthetic beauty and erotic desirability is dramatized in the ballet as the white and black swan, but is really meant to represent the contradictory criteria for feminine success. In this sense, it is a companion piece to Aronofsky’s previous film, The Wrestler, which explored mythologies of self-sufficient and virile masculinity. Many of the shots in each movie are composed in the same way, both deal with tensions between physical excellence and social failures, and both (who am I kidding, but spoiler alert) end in suicides.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

 

CLICK-FOR-CULTURAL-DISCOURSE

 

CLICK-FOR-VISIONARY-CREATIVITY

 

Contribute

 

Giant-Humans-Tiny-Worlds book cover

 

Post-Classic-Cinema-book
clickforpromovideo

 

Catastrophe book cover

 

newMedia-book

 

CELEBS-ICONS-book

 

Ebert books

Recent Posts

  • Animation Artistry in the Alps ~ by Larry Ruppel
  • Animated Cinematic Innovation Celebrated in the French Alps ~by Larry Ruppel
  • On Annihilation
  • On Blade Runner: 2049
  • On American Gods

Archives

Site

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Resources

  • Articles
  • Books
  • Classic Movies
  • Contact
  • Cookie Policy
  • Data Access Request
  • Help Support John Ebert
  • John David Ebert Movie Review of Being John Malkovich
  • John David Ebert Movie Review of Inland Empire
  • John David Ebert Movie Review of Lost Highway
  • John Lobell on Myths and Movies
  • Privacy Policy

John David Ebert Videos

click for video

Heidegger's Being and Time

click for video

Jean Gebser's Ever-Present Origin

click for video

Kant's Critique of Pure Reason

click for video

Fichte's Science of Knowledge

click for video

Schelling's First Outline of a System of the Philosophy of Nature

click for video

Karl Jaspers' Origin and Goal of History

click for video

Spengler's Decline of the West

click for video

Walter Benjamin's Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproducibility

click for video

Derrida's Of Grammatology

click for video

Horkheimer and Adorno's Dialectic of Enlightenment

click for video

Deleuze & Guattari's A Thousand Plateaus

click for video

Deleuze's Logic of Sense

click for video

Deleuze's Difference and Repetition

click for video

Vattimo's A Farewell to Truth

click for video

Alain Badiou's Ethics

click for video

The Works of Paul Virilio

click for video

Peter Sloterdijk's Spheres

click for video

John David Ebert on The Age of Catastrophe

click for video

John David Ebert on The New Media Invasion

click for video

John David Ebert on Elvis Presley

click for video

On Carroll Quigley and Historical Cycles

click for video

Heiner Muhlmann's Maximal Stress Cooperation Theory of Culture

click for video

On Borkenau's Cycle of the Dead

click for video

John David Ebert interviewed on Kubrick, Gilgamesh and the Dangers of Technology

click for video

John David Ebert Interviewed by the Artist Jacques de Beaufort

 

Click for John Lobell's Website

© 2014 John Lobell & John David Ebert | Webmaster jbQ Media Web & SEO

Manage Cookie Consent
We use cookies to optimize our website and our service.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}